A superiority result applies to a defined outcome, comparison, population and time point. SURMOUNT-5 found greater mean weight reduction with tirzepatide than semaglutide over 72 weeks in its tested population.
Superiority requires a defined comparison
A placebo-controlled retatrutide trial can establish superiority to its placebo for a prespecified endpoint. It cannot directly establish superiority to a treatment that was never assigned in that trial.
How to interpret the evidence
Ask which comparator was randomized before treating a result as a winner in a broader comparison.
Give the strongest weight to studies that randomized both treatments within a shared protocol for the clinical question you are asking.